Original Post: 3/5 stars
Before you go searching for the two missing stars from my rating, take into consideration several backstories before reading further:
1) I've been to Nicola's ONCE, and it was for Restaurant Week. That means my menu options were limited to several items from the regular menu, and none of these choices necessarily resembled anything I would have ordered had I had unlimited menu access.
2) For my main course, I had the Tagliatelle with Bolognese. I can count on my fingers and palm hairs the number of times I've eaten beef in my life (due to religious reasons), and almost always the occasion has been unavoidable. However, as Chris Rock says, "When Judgement Day comes, I refuse to believe that my diet will come into question." And a place like Nicola's must be making their own pasta, so I had test the difference that made from my own Meijer pasta adventures. Still, my stomach and pallet has not been acclimated to the taste of beef.
These backstories also serve as the backbone of my review, but since you've been so patient, I'll share some comments on the other dishes I tried:
CAPRESE SALAD - extremely fresh ingredients. Unfortunately, fancy restaurants don't list their menu items by weight, so the quantity is not going to win you over. Also, I'm not typically a salad person, but I fell sucker to the waiter's recommendation.
DIVER CAUGHT SEA SCALLOP - I usually think scallop is too squishy to be succulent, but I tried a bite from a friend's place, and must say, that was the best-tasting and best-cooked scallop I've ever tasted
TIRAMISU - very delicious, but rarely have I had bad tiramisu. The ingredients make the execution almost fool-proof. Trying to make terrible tiramisu is like trying to make a sloppy smoothie - as long as you follow the recipe, it's going to be tasty.
VANILLA PANNA COTTA - so fresh, so clean
I will say that the service is AMAZING, like to a level that is typically seen at a hotel rather than a restaurant. When it's time for a course to come out, a separate waiter comes out with each individual's dish, but the waiters all come out together and place the dish on the table at the same time. And they're all in black. It's like synchronized swimming meets the swat team meets Nicola's fun house.
However, the middle tier of menu items from Nicola's IS NOT tastier than top-tier Olive Garden selections. Nonetheless, it is a romantic place to take a date if your date likes medium-good food.